| Tackles |
| Most Tackles: Game |
| 1. |
24 - Derek Harsch (vs. Cowanesque) - 2000 |
| |
24 - Erich Crawford (vs. Lake Lehman) - 1994 |
| 2. |
21 - Jesse Tom (vs. Canton) - 2005 |
| |
21 - Dustin Harsch (vs. North Penn) - 2004 |
| |
21 - Colin McBride (vs. Cowanesque) - 2000 |
| |
21 - Brad Wilson (vs. Canton) - 1998 |
| 3. |
20 - Aaron Moss (vs. North Penn) - 2008 |
| |
20 - Jake Monks (vs. Towanda) - 2006 |
| |
20 - Derek Harsch (vs. North Penn) - 2000 |
| Most Tackles: Season |
| 1. |
146 - Kurt Benjamin - 1989 |
| 2. |
144 - Aaron Moss - 2008 |
| 3. |
119 - Jake Monks - 2006 |
| |
119 - Colie Stone - 2003 |
| Most Tackles: Career |
| 1. |
268 - Dustin Harsch - 2001-2004 |
| 2. |
259 - Colie Stone - 2001-2004 |
| 3. |
243 - Jake Monks - 2003-2006 |
| Sacks |
| Most Sacks: Game |
| 1. |
4 - Jeremy Walrath (vs. Sayre) - 2004 |
| |
4 - Bryan Kilmer (vs. Athens) - 1989 |
| 2. |
3 - Colton Acorn (vs. Troy, Athens) - 2007 |
| |
3 - Chris Copp (vs. Troy) - 2007 |
| |
3 - Jerry Heichel (vs. Cowanesque) - 2006 |
| |
3 - Chet Johnson (vs. Troy) - 2005 |
| 3. |
2 - Mitch Christman (vs. Troy) - 2008 |
| |
2 - Will Cornell (vs. Sayre) - 2007 |
| |
2 - John Johnston (vs. Athens) - 2002 |
| |
2 - Willie Blackwell (vs. Troy) - 2002 |
| |
2 - Bill Linder (vs. North Penn, Towanda) - 1994 |
| |
2 - Rob Kreger (vs. North Penn) - 1994 |
| |
2 - Rob Kreger (vs. Lewisburg) - 1993 |
| |
2 - Dan Reese (vs. Athens) - 1983 |
| Most Sacks: Season |
| 1. |
9 - Colton Acorn - 2007 |
| 2. |
8 - Chris Copp - 2007 |
| 3. |
7 - Jeremy Walrath - 2004 |
| Most Sacks: Career |
| 1. |
12 - Jeremy Walrath - 2001-2004 |
| 2. |
11 - Chris Copp - 2004-2007 |
| 3. |
10 - Willie Blackwell - 2001-2004 |
| Interceptions and Return Yards |
| Most Interceptions: Game |
| 1. |
3 - Jared Hurlbert (vs. Cowanesque) - 2000 |
| |
3 - Matt Kennedy (vs. Athens) - 1996 |
| |
3 - Jay Young (vs. Marian Catholic) - 1995 |
| 2. |
2 - Cameron Jones (vs. Canton) - 2008 |
| |
2 - Jake Coolidge (vs. Wyalusing, East Juniata) - 2008 |
| |
2 - Jake Coolidge (vs. Montgomery) - 2007 |
| |
2 - Tim Shaw (vs. Cowanesque) - 2006 |
| |
2 - Pat Clark (vs. Cowanesque) - 2005 |
| |
2 - Ian Carson (vs. Wyalusing) - 1994 |
| |
2 - Todd Wagaman (vs. Bucktail) - 1989 |
| |
2 - Jeff Zuchowski (vs. Athens) - 1988 |
| |
2 - Bob Bowers (vs. Wyalusing) - 1983 |
| |
2 - Jerry Carson (vs. Notre Dame) - 1977 |
| Most Interceptions: Season |
| 1. |
6 - Jake Coolidge - 2008 |
| |
6 - Matt Kennedy - 1996 |
| 2. |
5 - Tim Shaw - 2006 |
| |
5 - Jared Hurlbert - 2000 |
| |
5 - Ian Carson - 1994 |
| 3. |
4 - Jarred Regina - 1997 |
| |
4 - Matt Kennedy - 1996 |
| |
4 - Steve Radocaj - 1976 |
| Most Interceptions: Career |
| 1. |
11 - Jake Coolidge - 2005-2008 |
| 2. |
7 - Tim Shaw - 2003-2006 |
| |
7 - Matt Kennedy - 1994-1996 |
| 3. |
4 - Pat Coolidge - 2001-2004 |
| |
4 - Ed Baxter - 2001-2004 |
| |
4 - Steve Radocaj - 1974-1977 |
| Most Interception Yards: Game |
| 1. |
105 - Jarred Regina (vs. Sayre) - 1998 |
| 2. |
100 - Jake Coolidge (vs. Wyalusing) - 2008 |
| 3. |
93 - Jake Coolidge (vs. East Juniata) - 2008 |
| Most Interception Yards: Season |
| 1. |
271 - Jake Coolidge - 2008 |
| 2 |
105 - Jarred Regina - 1998 |
| 3 |
95 - Jared Hurlbert - 2000 |
| Most Interception Yards: Career |
| 1. |
326 - Jake Coolidge - 2005-2008 |
| 2. |
105 - Jarred Regina - 1995-1998 |
| 3. |
95 - Jared Hurlbert - 1997-2000 |
| Fumbles |
| Caused Fumbles: Game |
| 1. |
2 - Mitch Christman (vs. East Juniata) - 2008 |
| |
2 - Pat Driebelbies (vs. Towanda) - 2008 |
| |
2 - Aaron Moss (vs. Sayre) - 2008 |
| |
2 - Aaron Moss (vs. S. Williamsport) - 2007 |
| |
2 - Dontae Williams (vs. Canton) - 2004 |
| Caused Fumbles: Season |
| 1. |
5 - Mitch Christman - 2008 |
| 2. |
4 - Jesse Tom - 2006 |
| |
4 - Dontae Williams - 2004 |
| 3. |
3 - Aaron Moss - 2008 |
| |
3 - Mitch Christman - 2007 |
| |
3 - Aaron Moss - 2007 |
| |
3 - Ed Weaver - 2002 |
| Caused Fumbles: Career |
| 1. |
10 - Mitch Christman - 2005-2008 |
| 2. |
5 - Pat Driebelbies - 2005-2008 |
| |
5 - Jesse Tom - 2003-2006 |
| 3. |
4 - Dustin Harsch - 2001-2004 |
| |
4 - Dontae Williams - 2003-2004 |
| |
4 - Willie Blackwell - 2001-2004 |
| Recovered Fumbles: Game |
| 1. |
2 - Aaron Moss (vs. East Juniata) - 2008 |
| |
2 - Steve Mengee (vs. Sayre) - 2008 |
| |
2 - Dontae Williams (vs. Canton) - 2004 |
| |
2 - Jeremy Walrath (vs. Sayre) - 2002 |
| Recoverd Fumbles: Season |
| 1. |
4 - Steve Mengee - 2008 |
| |
4 - Dontae Williams - 2004 |
| |
4 - Jeremy Walrath - 2002 |
| 2. |
3 - Aaron Moss - 2008 |
| |
3 - Colton Acorn - 2007 |
| |
3 - Mitch Christman - 2007 |
| |
3 - Nate Luczak - 2007 |
| |
3 - Willie Blackwell - 2003 |
| |
3 - Rob Kreger - 1994 |
| 3. |
2 - Jake Monks - 2006 |
| |
2 - Pat Driebelbies - 2006 |
| |
2 - Tim Shaw - 2005 |
| Recovered Fumbles: Career |
| 1. |
7 - Jeremy Walrath - 2001-2004 |
| 2. |
5 - Steve Mengee - 2006-2008 |
| |
5 - Willie Blackwell - 2001-2004 |
| |
5 - Chase Kriner - 2000-2003 |
| 3. |
4 - Dustin Harsch - 2001-2004 |
| |
4 - Dontae Williams - 2003-2004 |